Puzzlement and Praxis in the Academic Library: Critically Reimagining Collection Practices with S…
Puzzlement and Praxis in the Academic Library: Critically Reimagining Collection Practices with Students
In Brief
This article mobilizes critical librarianship and critical/decolonial pedagogical strategies for disrupting and reconceiving collection practices in academic libraries. The authors—an academic librarian and a curriculum/pedagogy professor—argue that librarians can contend with the political tensions that underlie their collection management practices by actively questioning—or puzzling—with students and opening up library collections to students. The authors (a) highlight how undergraduate students were invited to engage with their library’s collection management
practices, (b) discuss examples of student-curated collections from a recent initiative, and (c) consider how the initiative informs current and future possibilities for student involvement in library work and knowledge management. In opening up the library collections to students, this work decenters the librarian-as-expert paradigm while also illustrating both the challenges and possibilities of demystifying and shifting our approach to information science.
By
Sarah Keener
and
Cee Carter
Introduction: Storying our Everyday Puzzlements
Figure 1
Several Student-Curated Featured Collections on the Library Shelf
When writing this article, Sarah Keener (she/her) was the library director for a small, rural college in the northeast. She’s had one foot in education and academia and the other in outdoor and hands-on trades for the entirety of her working life. This duality influences her interdisciplinary and expeditionary approach to the academic library, an approach that has also been shaped by the years she spent as a middle school teacher, school librarian, craft educator and student, and coach. As a white educator in a remote area that is socioeconomically diverse but predominantly white, the persistent sense of discomfort and uncertainty she confronts in this role arises largely from her inevitable participation in oppressive practices and colonial systems, and from the uneven power dynamics that seem inherent to being a teacher of any kind. This question, to paraphrase Maluski and Bruce (2022), has become central to her work and mission in education:
What is my role in dismantling oppressive practices?
Cee Carter is a fifth-generation Black woman educator and an Assistant Professor at the University of Vermont. Her previous work as a middle school educator and non-profit educational leader exposed the larger political economy of race that facilitates educational investments for reform. That is, how race is leveraged for policy intervention and profit in public education. In response, her scholarly work aims to shift normative curricular and pedagogical practices (Sykes, 2011)—asking more of how we construct and pursue our conceptions of justice in the era of neoliberal public education reform (Carter, 2024). A question that animates her educational inquiry is:
Ho…